Monday, December 5, 2011

MArooned Product Review: SIG SAUER Mosquito

A while back, the good folks at SIG SAUER sent me a Mosquito for review earlier this year. After taking it to the range quite a few times, and having different folks shoot it (including my son!), here’s my review.

SIG SAUER Mosquito

History:

The SIG SAUER Mosquito was released in 2005, the first rimfire offering for SIG SAUER. It was designed as a .22LR training version of their stalwart P226 model line, designed with the same controls as the P226 in a package that was 10% smaller overall. It’s a traditional DA/SA design semi-automatic, blowback operated, with a polymer frame and an aluminum-zinc alloy slide. The barrel is fixed, differentiating the Mosquito from its larger centerfire brethren and allowing for increased accuracy.

Much has been made of the choice by SIG SAUER to go with the zinc-aluminum alloy for the slide, with detractors claiming that the mixture is inferior to straight aluminum or steel. In this particular model there were no defects observed in the slide after shooting well in excess of 1,000 rounds, so in this reviewer’s experience this claim has not proven valid. Even during rapid-fire testing, with several hundred rounds fired as quickly as possible, no undue stress was placed on the firearm.

Impressions:

The Mosquito makes quite a handy training tool for those familiar with the full-sized centerfire models. The controls are in the same place, the feel and function are similar, only the addition of a safety differentiates it from a P226 externally.

Controls

The takedown, owing to the fixed barrel, is slightly different – the takedown lever rotates 180º rather than 90º on the P226. Obviously, recoil and capacity are different as well.

Disassembled

The Mosquito’s smaller size makes it a valuable addition to the line for new shooters and those with smaller hands (especially younger shooters). The fit and finish on the model reviewed here were excellent, with smooth operation of all levers and tight lockup between slide and frame. The safety is simple and easy to operate with one hand, as is the standard SIG SAUER decocking lever. It disassembles quickly and easily with no difficulties and goes back together in a similar effortless manner. No third arm required on this .22!

Shooting the Mosquito.

The first trip to the range with the Mosquito made it evident that the “breaking in” period was much-needed. In 150 rounds, it had several failures to eject, a couple stovepipes, and one time it failed to chamber the second round. A thorough cleaning later, the second trip yielded a couple stovepipes and one failure to eject over another 150 rounds. The next three trips of 150 rounds each, though, were flawless - I found myself forgetting to take notes the Mosquito was running so well. The last trip started off with one failure to load, but was otherwise uneventful.

All of the previous testing was performed using the SIG SAUER recommended CCI mini-mag ammunition. For my last trip, I brought 50 – 100 rounds of several different brands and manufacturers:

Fiocchi 40 gr CP
PMC “Zapper” 38 gr HP
PMC “Sidewinder” 40 gr LRN
Federal Champion 40 gr LRN
Federal Bulk 36 gr CP
Remington Thunderbolt 40 gr LRN

Sadly, the Mosquito did NOT like my favorite Federal bulk .22LR ammunition, nor did it care for the PCM “Sidewinder” or the Federal Champion. The Fiocchi worked well, about 75% success, and the PMC Zapper was fine as well. The real surprise was finding that the Mosquito simply loved the Remington Thunderbolt, which I’ve found to be a little dirtier than most and doesn’t agree with some .22LR semi-automatics I’ve shot due to the lead round nose bullet.

Where the Mosquito excels, though, is in its accuracy. Whether slow-fire or rapid fire at 10 yards, or slow-fire at 50 yards, the accuracy of the Mosquito was superb:

Targets, part one

But the most telling were the two targets used in the ammunition testing range trip:

Targets, part two

These targets were placed at about 10 yards, and then magazines were emptied as fast as possible for many different types of ammunition. Any aiming was purely coincidental; the front sight was placed roughly in the vicinity of the center of the target and then the trigger was pulled. Lather, rinse, repeat. One target has 60 rounds; the other 80 or more (probably closer to 100). For a pistol with an MSRP of $390 (and a shelf price generally around $300), that’s pretty impressive accuracy under the stated conditions (i.e. I was not doing anything even remotely resembling carefully aimed fire).

Conclusion:

SIG SAUER’s entry in the world of rimfire semi-automatic pistols has its plusses and minuses. On the plus side, it’s very accurate and easy to take apart for cleaning; on the minus, it’s finicky about ammo (preferring, naturally, the more expensive variety – it *is* Teutonic, after all). If there's a P226 or a P229 in your armory and you'd like a companion rimfire piece, it's the logical choice; ditto if you're looking for an inexpensive plinker that functions similar to your favorite centerfire DA/SA handgun.

This is one Mosquito that doesn't bite!

That is all.

10 comments:

libertyman said...

Do they still give you two different springs? One is for lighter loads. Did you try swapping springs for the other .22s?

I like mine, and it is remarkably accurate. It has not failed to feed or eject for a long time. The slide is die cast and the frame is injection molded, both do their jobs well. It fits my hand remarkably well, and it is inexpensive. I'll keep mine, and maybe you can get a deal on that one.

Mopar said...

Another fan of the skeeter over here. A few things things you didn't mention though. First is that oil hole on the right side of the slide. You are supposed to add a drop of oil there every 150-200rnds or so. Speaking of lube, it does like to be kinda wet, and it really does like the lube specifies (and even includes with the gun), Mil-Comm TW-25B. Giving all friction points a thin coating of that really seems to help. We've also noticed ours seems to like the crappy Thunderbolt ammo as well, go figure. Ours also likes the Federal AutoMatch, which isn't as cheap as the Champion, but still cheaper then the minimags.
Last.... I don't know if you remember, but when we were at Sig last winter Cheryl brought up ammo issue with them. At the time it was explained that because Sig is a European company, they designed the gun using European .22 ammo. Because gun use is generally more restrictive over there, they don't have/use low cost "bulk" .22 like we do for plinking. Heck, they don't really plink there at all. All the ammo is match grade type stuff. The Sig guy (I forgot his name, sorry!) told us then that they were aware of the problem and they were redesigning the gun for the USA market. Looks like a year later that hasn't happened yet.

A little side story about European .22 ammo. The president of my club is in his mid 70s and from Germany. He said when he lived there, .22 was so scarce and expensive that they used to reload it! They mainly used single shot bolt action rifles, and you had to make sure when you loaded the round that it was oriented so that the firing pin would strike a fresh part of the rim.

Ross said...

How's the weight, Jay? My Ruger Mark I & II are a bit heavy for younger or more delicately-framed shooters - but I've heard too many bad things to want to pick up Walther P22 for teaching kids and ladies.

Jay G said...

libertyman,

I'd have to go back and look through the box, but I don't recall a second spring. That may have been the first generation Mosquito.

Mopar,

Good point about the oil. I tend not to use it, because I generally don't put more than ~ 200 rounds in a single outing through any gun, and I am {ahem} a little on the fanatical side about cleaning...

Interesting point about the .22 ammo. The CCI mini-mags really aren't that bad - I can get 100 at WalMart for $7, compared to 550 of the Federal bulk for $19. Sure, it's more pricey, but if you can supplement with Rem Thunderbolt... ;)

Ross,

The weight is just about perfect - it's light enough that younger shooters don't have any trouble holding it for lengthy (> 1 mag) periods of time, but substantial enough that it absorbs what little recoil .22LR produces.

Excellent points, all!

.45ACP+P said...

We love the "Skeeter" especially as a training tool. Taking new shooters to the range it gives us a practical oportunity to train on jams. We deliberately use ammo it does not like and it gives real time experience on clearing a stoppage (usually a stovepipe). I find this s useful quirk, not a fault. After 50 to 100 rounds, the comptence of the new shooter is greatly increased and not just on accuracy.

Robert said...

"The Fiocchi worked well, about 75% success"

You consider 75% to be working well? I sure don't.

Jay G said...

Robert,

Fair point, that.

When compared to other ammunition that would not function at all, 75% success rate was pretty good. Not to mention that at the point I tried the Fiocchi, the Mosquito was absolutely filthy...

libertyman said...

I should also add, I have been careless about cleaning and lube --(Mopar - I had forgotten about the Sig recommended lube regimen, I must say) My new shooter liked it, and did very well at 25 yards, in fact, remarkably well with it.
Mine is the two toned silver slide and black body, and it looks nice, too.

Daniel in Brookline said...

I liked it a lot too. Jay, thanks again for letting yours be test-driven by me and my eleven-year-old! "Try before you buy" is a nice luxury indeed for firearms.

Now, I just need to make time to get to the range more often, so that I can break mine in thoroughly before MIss Z finds out I have it...

hgriffin1 said...

Just picked up a Skeeter in the OD Green with the treaded barrel a week ago. 750+ rounds with similar issues noted for non-CCI rounds. It seems to be getting more forgiving as more rounds are passed through it as one might expect. I really love this pistol!!! It's a lot of fun to shoot and really feels great in my larger hands. My grandsons had a blast with it as well though I am now personna non gratta at their home for a while....