Tuesday, July 10, 2012

I Wonder...

Okay, okay. Everyone and their brother has sent me the story about the Detroit cop whose service pistol magically fired while in a holster, killing the woman dancing behind him. The story goes that she went to hug the officer - who was dancing with his wife - when somehow the officer's gun fired, striking her directly in the chest and killing her almost instantly.

My take? The wife got pissed off, grabbed her husband's gun, and shot the woman. Here she is, dancing with her husband, when some sweet young thing comes up and starts trying to do the horizontal mambo with her man. She gets mad, grabs his gun, [BANG] and then the bullshit of "it somehow went off" becomes the coverup story.

It's either that or the giant talking broccoli stalks from Planet Weembo getting out of hand...

Look, it's quite simple. The story is a crock of shit. Holstered guns do not discharge on their own. Period. Full stop. Guns carried IWB are almost always pointed down, especially a full-sized service pistol. There is simply no way this woman could have accidentally pulled the gun out of the holster, gotten something inside the trigger guard, *AND* shot herself in the chest with the gun. This is either the most bizarre case of suicide-by-cop ever, or a pissed off wife.

Especially knowing that the thin blue line would protect and serve one of their own...

That is all.

13 comments:

Bubblehead Les. said...

What I find interesting is how the Detroit Police Chief declared it a "Tragic Accident" that wasn't his Officer's Fault.

Amazing how he could say that, w/o a Coroner's Report.

Or a Ballistics Report from the State Crime Lab.

Or a Report from whatever the Detroit CSI is called.

Or any other Forensic Evidence.

Just a Magic Gun that can turn itself around in a Holster and Fire itself with just a Hug.

Must be nice to have those Psychic Superpowers, huh?

Weer'd Beard said...

Man the story keeps changing.

Yeah there's GOT to be a LOT more to this story!

The least sinister option is some riske grinding going on, and he was carrying Mexican-Style and the gun slipped and he made a grab and hit the trigger.

No way this could have happened if he was carrying IWB in a holster like the stories have said.

Dave H said...

There's been some conjecture that he might have been carrying the gun in a shoulder rig, with the muzzle pointed backwards. It still doesn't explain how the trigger "accidentally" got pulled.

That's like when my daughter "accidentally" duct-taped her sister to the bedpost when she was 8.

Anonymous said...

My first thought was "Mexican Carry" too, Weerd.

Or maybe Sumdood has been working with the Brady bunch and has perfected a remote control gun-firing device. This was the first test. (Yeah, I need more coffee.)

LittleRed1

Bram said...

Nope - the gun was carried at his "waisteline".
http://www.detroitnews.com/article/20120709/METRO01/207090365/

It must have magically fired backwards when the trigger magically depressed in the holster.

Jay G said...

Dave,

Every report I've read has said nylon holster IWB. I've heard nothing about a shoulder rig, although the way this story changes it wouldn't surprise me...

Laura said...

i figured it out, Jay. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbRZKrvAZ7U

Dave H said...

My mistake. The chatter I heard apparently started before details about his holster came out.

Maybe Miss Manners there was trying to find out if he really was happy to see her, and reached into the wrong pocket.

Daniel in Brookline said...

Yeah, I wondered the same thing too. His gun is in its holster at his waist, and it goes off and hits her in the chest???

Either he's two feet taller than her, putting her chest at his waist level, or... nah, better not go there.

Dragon said...

Lets see...

Gun IWB in cheap nylon holster...

Girl hugging him from behind, gun goes off, strikes girl in chest...

Someone explain to me what her tata's were doing dancing with his bupkus, with her hands obviously fingering his *AHEM* "weapon", while she was standing? Is she a midget?

>>Bow-chicka-bow-wow!<<

Because thats the only way I can figure that all these parts lined up for this to happen.

Anonymous said...

DPD Service pistols have an 8 to 10 lb trigger Pull. It's tough to have an "intentional" discharge let alone an ND

Adam said...

It was a smith and wesson M&P 40... 6.5 pound trigger pull, and it has the ridiculous goofy segmented trigger. They are hard enough to shoot when you are trying to shoot them, never mind through your pants and an IWB holster. Agreed with Jay, this story is completely unbelievable. As my coworker from MIT is wont to say when he hears something stupid: It is intuitively obvious to the most casual of observers that you are wrong.

Ed said...

Colonel Jeff Cooper's Four Rules of Gun Safety:
1. All guns are always loaded.
2. Never let the muzzle cover anything you are not willing to destroy.
3. Keep your finger off the trigger until your sights are on the target.
4. Be sure of your target and what is beyond it.

You are responsible for what your weapon does, no exceptions. If you are unable to accept this, unload the weapon. Blaming a soft holster that does not adequately cover a trigger is unacceptable. Blaming a hug from someone in back of you is unacceptable.